Customer Acquisition Marketing: Hard Lessons I’ve Learned Over 25 Years

Dec 24, 2019 | Marketing

Marketing Blog

Next year will mark a quarter-century since I launched my own customer acquisition marketing business. Here is how a chance encounter set me on the path to entrepreneurship. After college, I had landed my first real sales job at a direct marketing company. In 1994, I was asked to speak at a Chamber of Commerce event. Afterward, a financial advisor approached me. He said he was looking for an effective way to attract older Americans interested in hiring him to manage their finances and assist them with retirement planning.

I understood back then that the 50+ age group was wary of advisors and guarded. They wouldn’t visit an advisor at the office, or welcome one into their home. But, I thought, some would be open to an educational seminar offered in a neutral environment.

Birthing the Social Seminar Concept

So, I hatched an idea to find new clients for financial advisors and estate planning professionals: social seminars. These could create meaningful engagements between clients and motivated prospects. As fate would have it, the financial advisor’s brother-in-law managed several restaurants for a well-known seafood chain. It would become the neutral environment I was looking for.

When I got back to the office, I developed a personalized invitation and mailed out 5,000 of them on behalf of the advisor. It not only generated 250 RSVPs, but the advisor also had to hire two administrative assistants to handle the phone calls and coordinate four events. Encouraged by the success of that customer acquisition marketing campaign, I founded Response Mail Express (RME) the following year with a few partners.

Soon, we had a client roster of 200 financial advisors, all eager to find clients age 55 and up with retirement questions to be answered and income to invest.

Making Decisions and Taking Chances

Like many people do in December, I recently found myself reflecting on the past year. Then I cast my memory even further back in time. I recalled that to get where I am today, I made my share of mistakes. Obviously, the social seminar concept wasn’t one of them. However, I made several missteps in the process of rolling it out.

First, I didn’t nail down accurate demographics for prospects in the areas where my clients were doing business. As a result, I targeted some of the wrong people to attend the seminars.

Additional miscalculations included:

  • Selecting the wrong type of venues
  • choosing the wrong days of the week
  • picking the wrong hours of the day for clients to host events

Believing in Your Process

You don’t become an industry leader overnight. In the early days, I allowed financial advisors and insurance agents to choose what they wanted to promote. What’s more, I let them direct where they preferred to have their events, and even how to market themselves. It was more convenient for them.

But it clashed with my purpose, which was to meet the needs of their target audiences. This group enjoyed learning more about complex services and products in a comfortable setting. They preferred being among others like themselves…safety in numbers.

Trusting Your Marketing Instincts

Since the dawn of time, human beings have connected and bonded with each other over meals. So, I incorporated a social dinner into the seminar process. This transformed it into a no-pressure, relaxed evening out for the participants. Not only did it keep the audience at the venue for an hour or so after the presentation, it freed the advisor and staff to socialize with attendees and allowed the staff to schedule appointments. I came to realize this seminar marketing approach could work in other industries sharing the same target demographic. Despite our growing track record of success, though, I still could not convince some potential advisor customers that marketing is an investment, rather than an expense.

Keeping Target Audience Top-of-Mind

Here is the most important lesson I took away from the errors I made early in my career:

Put the consumer first.

When it comes to customer acquisition marketing, I found that people don’t respond to sales pitches. They prefer to be educated. As LeadingResponse grew, we tinkered with the formula, refined seminar topics, and tweaked the event marketing process. We focused on understanding the consumer’s journey, viewed through the lens of their financial needs. After nearly 25 years and 1,000,000 social seminars, we’ve accumulated a volume of response data allowing us to pinpoint who our clients’ ideal customers are.

In mid-2019, RME was re-imagined and branded as LeadingResponse. Today, the company has 160 dedicated employees and thousands of clients.

Learning From Your Errors

As you advance in your career, you’re bound to stumble at some point. That’s not necessarily a bad thing. In fact, there is scientific proof mistakes can lead to greater career achievements. It’s even documented in a New York Times article, “How Early-Career Setbacks Can Set You Up for Success.

Look where I am today – still in the seminar marketing business. I didn’t let mistakes stop me. You don’t have to, either.

To find out more about how we help professionals in the financial, estate planning, elective medical and senior living industries connect with those interested in your services, contact us today.



Popular Topics
A dart sits at the bullseye of a target on a desk, next to a laptop, glasses, pen, and notebook.
Apr 11 2024

How LeadingResponse Delivers Quality Legal Case Leads

Having the right tools at your disposal can make all the difference in your legal marketing efforts. LeadingResponse offers cutting-edge legal...
A stethoscope and a card that reads 'medicare' sit on a yellowish green background.
Apr 06 2024

Medicare 2025: Your Guide to the Latest Changes and What They Mean for You

CMS just rolled out the latest on Medicare Advantage (MA) and Part D Payment Policies for 2025. Here’s what these changes mean for you and...
Business men sitting at a desk, going over graphs and financial reports.
Mar 28 2024

10 Creative Marketing Ideas for Financial Advisors

How do you effectively market your services as a financial advisor and stand out in a competitive landscape? In this blog post, we’re going to...
Man with a crutch meets with and shakes hands with his personal injury attorney
Mar 14 2024

5 Tips for Your Personal Injury Marketing Plan

A well-crafted plan can set you apart from the rest. To help you achieve this, here are five crucial tips to consider when developing your personal...
Financial advisor works on his phone, with metrics out on his desk. His phone glows with light bulb, productivity, and growth icons.
Feb 01 2024

Unlocking Growth: The Crucial Role of Marketing for Financial Advisors

Finding clients as a financial advisor can be complicated. In an era marked by dynamic shifts in the financial services sector, the need for...
Formal handshake
Jan 22 2024

Unlock Success: Your Guide to Outsourcing Legal Marketing

Effective lead generation is essential for business strategy and cash flow and plays a pivotal role in supporting the financial growth of your...
Young black woman speaking into a podcast microphone
Jan 17 2024

2024 Performance Marketing Trends to Watch

For those who are well-versed in performance marketing and want to know more about marketing trends, keep reading fort the anticipated marketing...
Close up of estate planner shaking hands with new client
Jan 15 2024

5 Tips To Get High Quality Estate Planning Leads

Estate planning leads is a niche market, and knowing how to find the right prospects can be daunting. If you’re ready to see a significant...
Get More Leads
Jan 08 2024

The Hottest Mass Tort Leads for 2024

Is your law firm looking to expand this year? If so, then lead generation should be your top priority. Getting the best legal leads doesn’t have to...
Man draws his business growth rising
Jan 04 2024

5 Ways to Improve Conversion Rates in Client Acquisition

Discover 5 effective strategies to boost conversion rates in client acquisition. Learn how to optimize your marketing efforts and maximize...
Professional woman sits on a chair to the right, in front of a large yellow wall. Drawings display "PPC" and internet connectivity symbols to the left.
Dec 28 2023

The Ultimate Guide to PPC Advertising Best Practices

Pay-Per-Click (PPC) advertising, aka search engine marketing, is a potent tool for digital marketing. With PPC ads, businesses can reach more of...
Professional man works on his laptop keyboard, a pen in his hand as he types. An internet search bar is over the image.
Dec 20 2023

A Comprehensive Guide to Search Engine Marketing

In today’s online-driven world, businesses compete to capture the attention of their target audience with more and more competition each...

Now is the time to grow your business for tomorrow. Ready to get started?

We respect your right to privacy.